Can You Imagine Your Life Without an Eating Disorder? A new examination shows new perspectives you can act on.
By Joanna Poppink, MFT
Summary
An eating disorder consumes time, intelligence, emotional capacity, and strength. When a woman asks what her life might be without those demands, she discovers the truth of her own potential. This single question can awaken a moment of freedom and open a path to healing.
The Question and Answer
A question that often awakens a woman living with an eating disorder is this:
If I used all the time, energy, planning, intelligence, and emotional focus I devote to my eating disorder for something else, what could I do in my life.
The responses rarely come boldly. They arrive in a quiet voice, often with a hand covering the mouth, as if a forbidden truth has surfaced.
- I could run five Fortune 500 companies.
I could make a real impact on the world.
I could finish my PhD, my law, or my medical training.
I could leave this destructive relationship and care for my children.
I could write my book. Make my film. Start my business. Build my school.
I could discover what I am actually capable of.
Meaning
These realizations do not arise from fantasy. They arise from the recognition that an eating disorder commands a woman’s intelligence, creativity, stamina, judgment, and emotional force. She feels the weight of the system she has been maintaining and senses what might be possible if her capacities were free.
When you take inventory of everything you think, plan, hide, control, manage, or endure each day to uphold an eating disorder, and then imagine using those same resources for something that supports your real life, you feel a moment of expansion. The sensation is physical. It is emotional. It feels and is real.
You may not know what to do next. You may not know how to begin. Yet something opens. Possibility touches you and reaches through the disorder’s grip. Many women enter psychotherapy because of this moment. Others need someone to ask the question before they can imagine change.
Women's Response
When I ask this question in the therapy room, I watch faces shift. Eyes fill. Voices tremble. A woman sees a part of herself she thought was gone. The moment can feel like loss and hope at the same time. It marks the beginning of a deep healing journey that restores dignity and truth.
Truth Revealed
An eating disorder does not grow in weakness. It grows in capability. To maintain the disorder, a woman relies on psychological strengths that are often unrecognized.
She uses intelligence, planning, strategic adaptation, commitment, endurance, strength, organizational skill, resourcefulness, acting ability, persuasion, diligence, determination, and complex strategizing.
These are proven capacities. The eating disorder harnesses them for its own survival. Recovery requires turning these same strengths toward a life that honors you.
The central question becomes:
How can you redirect these qualities to support a life that reflects your truth.
Everything you need has already been demonstrated. Your abilities are strong. They belong to you. Healing begins when they return to your service.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does this question bring such a strong emotional reaction?
A woman suddenly sees her own potential. She realizes her intelligence and abilities were never lost. The eating disorder captured them. The glimpse of what could be is both painful and hopeful. It feels and is real.
Does recognizing these strengths make recovery easier?
Recognizing these strengths makes recovery possible. It does not remove the need for real work. It creates inner permission to begin. Recovery develops through honesty, courage, consistency, and support.
Is it too late to reclaim my life if I have lived with an eating disorder for years?
No. Women reclaim their authority at all ages. The capacities that once upheld the disorder can build a life that holds meaning.
What if the possibilities I imagine frighten me?
Fear appears when a woman steps toward her truth. The effort to live behind a false identity becomes too painful to continue. Fear still exists, but it no longer decides her direction. Her psyche turns her toward what supports her real life.
If the key question opens something in you, the shift is meaningful. A woman reaches a point at which the price of the disorder can no longer be justified. She senses the beginning of her return. Her strength rises through her symptoms and points her toward the life she can live.
Resources
Internal resources from this site:
Following the False Map of Love
Reversing the Narcissist’s Gaze
When the Bark Splits
External resources:
National Eating Disorders Association.
Academy for Eating Disorders.
About Joanna Poppink, MFT
Joanna Poppink, MFT, is a depth-oriented psychotherapist specializing in psychotherapy for midlife women, eating disorder recovery, and recovery from the impacts of narcissistic abuse. She is licensed in California, Arizona, Florida, and Oregon, and offers secure virtual sessions. If you sense your deeper self pressing upward and are ready to explore this work, you are welcome to reach out. For a free telephone consultation, write
You may begin with the series introduction here.
Add comment